Comments on: Progress, No Matter the Cost https://helterskelter.in/2011/09/progress-no-matter-the-cost/ Fresh Voices and New Writing From and About India Thu, 27 Mar 2014 10:13:27 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.4.5 By: Kaber Vasuki https://helterskelter.in/2011/09/progress-no-matter-the-cost/comment-page-1/#comment-840 Wed, 04 Dec 2013 05:46:00 +0000 http://helterskelter.in/?p=3668#comment-840 While I don’t like many things about Modi and will be voting for him only because there is no other alternative to the Congress, I think you are greatly exaggerating the dangers of the man by comparing him to Hitler.

Hitler’s rhetoric during his ascent was focused on the greatness of the Aryan race. At that point in Germany’s history, the country was in shambles after World War I and no one had any hope for the future of the country. When people had nothing to be proud of, he told them it wasn’t their fault that Gemany was in shambles – it was the fault of the ruling class and the business class and the elite. The most visible among them were the Jews and so he extended the argument that in an Aryan nation the Jews have control and have brought an Aryan nation down and so they must be kicked out of power and the Aryans must once again build their country and bring it back to glory.

In Indian media terms – his rhetoric was highly communal.

If he were to contest as a Hindu Nationalist candidate today – he would be talking about the glory if the Hindu religion and of how the Muslims have been the ones who destroyed a great nation and brought it to shambles. While Hindu Nationalists do speak of a glorious Hindu past and there is considerable anger among them against the Muslim community, that rhetoric is not Modi’s rhetoric.

Modi’s rhetoric is tamer and the anti-Muslim sentiment will not work throughout the country – which means he will have to hold it in. Will be become anti-Muslim once he is in power? That remains to be seen, but Modi declaring Emergency, although scary to think about, doesn’t seem like a possibility to me.

]]>
By: Ahmed https://helterskelter.in/2011/09/progress-no-matter-the-cost/comment-page-1/#comment-375 Mon, 12 Sep 2011 17:52:00 +0000 http://helterskelter.in/?p=3668#comment-375 Its strange to see a political piece in Helter Skelter. Nevertheless, I think India is too large a country, with its rich diversity and vibrant culture, and Modi, too small minded as a leader, to effectively balance diverse interests and manage these nations within the nations. I don’t believe he has a grasp of problems and challenges, while being adept at projecting an image of someone who is all about development. To add to this, we have the ghost of Godhra, something which he should clearly take blame for, and its a fact that can’t be wished away. 
Besides, development is not just swanky buildings and new SUV’s on the road. While all this may have come in while pandering to corporate interests, have mindsets changed? Do we have a more liberal and progressive society? Are we more tolerant than we have been in the past? I’m not so sure.

]]>
By: Anonymous https://helterskelter.in/2011/09/progress-no-matter-the-cost/comment-page-1/#comment-374 Mon, 12 Sep 2011 16:03:00 +0000 http://helterskelter.in/?p=3668#comment-374 You summed up my thoughts to perfection. I live in Ahmedabad now. It scares me how the people of the city, many of them at least, can only see the development side to him. That is perfectly great. But what about the dark side that is not understood and sometimes unseen?

Well put. :)

]]>